I Hate Twitter as an Author Platform

Hey all! I am sure that since we are all actively participating in the online writing community, we have seen the recent twitter fallout that has caused two major book releases to be cancelled. If you haven’t, check out this article explaining the recent events, and I will do my best to summarize it below.

Amélie Wen Zhao wrote and secured an advance of at least $500,000 with Delacorte for her debut trilogy on the strength of the first novel Blood Heir. Months before the novel was slated to be released, a few book reviewers went to twitter stating that the ARC continued racists themes. Ultimately, they viewed her depiction of slavery, which was inspired from Asian history, as being insensitive due to how they perceived through the lens of American slavery.

Due to the mass outrage this sparked on twitter, well before the vast majority of people had a chance to read the book and judge it on their own, Zhao ended up requesting to pull the book from publication. This mob justice is the sort of thing that I think runs rampant on twitter and it is not isolated to only the YA crowds.

Twitter seems to thrive on the outrage culture. Whenever I scroll through my feed, it seems that every other post is talking about how everything is awful, on fire, or is a gross generalization about entire demographics of people. (Facebook isn’t much better, truth be told. I personally enjoy the writing communities on reddit the most.)

I think twitter has some great aspects. All of the pitch events are a great resource, and it allows writers to keep up with current events in the publishing world in real time—I would have never heard about Zhao had the twitter stuff propelled her into the spotlight. In fact, twitter is how people can see when publishing jobs open up (i.e. PodCastle just put out a call for two more slush readers.)

I don’t plan on leaving twitter anytime soon, but I don’t plan to post often. I feel that it just isn’t quite my thing, but more power to everyone who is killing it on there. Thanks for reading, and if you haven’t hit the subscribe button below, it would be freaking awesome if you did!

3 thoughts on “I Hate Twitter as an Author Platform

  1. I completely agree with your assessment of the Twitter outrage. It is absurd. I think most people tweeting angry things don’t care as much as they pretend to. Getting on the outrage bandwagon is a means to get more attention. Perhaps I’m wrong, but that is my impression. How many of these same folks would be fuming if asked about this book (or any topic they expressed anger over) in real life? I would guess some might restate their tweet and move on with their lives.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I am struck by how impotent we all are in evaluating both the book and the advance reviews. None of us have read the book. I resent not having had the opportunity to form my own judgment. Is it wrong to portray racism or does it depend on whether or not the theme is perceived as racist? I have so many questions.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s